arrow_back Back to forum
Quantum Computing 5 days ago

ibm said quantum advantage would be confirmed by the end of 2026. its november

by Tariq

genuine question from a maths teacher who only half follows this. about a year ago IBM said they expected the first cases of verified quantum advantage to be confirmed by the wider community by the end of 2026. this month theyve switched on a System Two in Chicago and have their developer conference on, and quantinuum put out a new roadmap last week so did it happen? and how would someone like me even tell. every few weeks theres a headline saying a quantum computer beat a supercomputer, then a month later someone finds a faster classical way to do the same thing my year 11s ask me this and my honest answer is "no idea, ask in five years", which isnt great teaching what would actually count, for those of you who know?

favorite 2 comment 2

Comments

Daniel Cohen 5 days ago

Tariq, "ask in five years" is closer to right than you think, but you can give them something sharper. A useful test has three parts. The problem has to be one someone actually cares about, not one picked because the hardware happens to be good at it. The answer has to be checkable. And it has to survive a few months of classical people trying to beat it, which is where most of those headlines fell over. We have decent results on the first two for narrow physics simulations. Nobody has cleared all three in a way the field agrees on yet. There's now a public tracker where claims get challenged in the open, which is a healthy change. For your class: "probably soon, chemistry first, and argued about for a year after".

Ava Engel 4 days ago

Tariq, Daniel's three-part test is the right one, but I'd soften "chemistry first" for your year 11s. The first results that clear all three bars will probably be simulations of fairly exotic physics, magnets and the like, that a few hundred researchers care about. Useful to them, invisible to everyone else. If the class expects a new drug or battery out of it, the real thing will feel like a letdown. Early flight might work as an analogy for teenagers. The first hops were real and also useless for getting anywhere. The interesting question is what the third or fourth version does, and a couple of your students could well be the people who find out.

Log in to join the discussion.